Advertisement
The expansion of bus stops

A one-way street of thinking

In many places, the expansion of bus stops to make them accessible to disabled people is being used to implement new ‘traffic calming measures’. For many road users, this is an absolute nuisance and a step in the wrong direction, criticises our author Erwin Kartnaller.
Erwin Kartnaller
THE KEY POINTS IN BRIEF
• The expansion of bus stops is intended to improve accessibility, but often leads to traffic congestion.
• Many measures are expensive and have a negative impact on traffic flow and the environment.
• Social helpfulness in public transport is being sacrificed to ‘modern’ ways of thinking.

As a result of the Dis­abil­i­ty Dis­crim­i­na­tion Act, bus stops through­out Switzer­land are being struc­tural­ly adapt­ed. In total, mil­lions of Swiss francs will prob­a­bly be spent on this – if there is enough mon­ey avail­able. How­ev­er, this ‘equal­i­ty’ mea­sure is now hin­der­ing the flow of traf­fic because, as part of this con­struc­tion work, bus bays have been/are being removed in many places and bus­es now stop in the mid­dle of the road. This rais­es the sus­pi­cion that an orig­i­nal­ly well-inten­tioned pro­pos­al is being exploit­ed to imple­ment fur­ther harass­ment mea­sures that can be sold under the appeal­ing term of ‘traf­fic calm­ing mea­sures’. In this respect, the state, its plan­ners and oth­er sub­or­di­nates are extreme­ly resource­ful and will­ing to imple­ment such mea­sures, which is some­thing that is rather lack­ing when it comes to oth­er press­ing neces­si­ties. Many res­i­dents along such routes, and numer­ous motorists who use this route to com­mute to work, are less than enthu­si­as­tic about this inter­ven­tion in road traf­fic. They vent their anger in con­ver­sa­tions.

A one-way street of thinking

In my imme­di­ate vicin­i­ty alone, I can’t even count on two hands the num­ber of exam­ples where traf­fic calm­ing mea­sures have been tak­en to extremes. The pic­ture accom­pa­ny­ing the arti­cle shows a bus route that leads to a rur­al area. Over a dis­tance of less than three kilo­me­tres, road traf­fic is brought to a stand­still sev­er­al times at short inter­vals, at prac­ti­cal­ly every bus stop.

In the imme­di­ate vicin­i­ty of where I live, I can tell you about two bus stops that were equipped with a pedes­tri­an under­pass at the request of the local pop­u­la­tion. But what hap­pens? Many of the pas­sen­gers, when they switch to the role of pedes­tri­ans, jump out behind the bus onto the road. On one bus route with a dense timetable and high traf­fic vol­ume, the bus stop has now also been adapt­ed in accor­dance with the Dis­abil­i­ty Dis­crim­i­na­tion Act. At the same time, the bus bay has been removed, which can­not be attrib­uted to the spa­tial con­di­tions. Stops are becom­ing more fre­quent, and CO2 emis­sions are ris­ing as a result of motorised vehi­cles stop­ping and accel­er­at­ing again more often.

In this con­text, I would like to men­tion that I have not seen pedes­tri­an cross­ings paint­ed on the road at the exit of round­abouts in any oth­er coun­try. Just think about it: human beings (lives) are being used as a traf­fic calm­ing mea­sure! What is pre­vail­ing here can only be described as a one-way street of think­ing – ide­ol­o­gy is equat­ed with intel­li­gence, there­by pro­mot­ing bound­less stu­pid­i­ty.

Relational nonsense is allowed when others pay for it

In terms of pub­lic trans­port, it start­ed much ear­li­er. There was a time when bus oper­a­tors were required to install lifts for dis­abled peo­ple in their bus­es. Cost fac­tor: 20,000 to 30,000 Swiss francs per bus. The oper­a­tor of a pub­lic bus line in a tourist com­mu­ni­ty in Graubün­den once cal­cu­lat­ed for me: ‘We used this lift only once in a year.’ So it’s fair to say that this was a waste of mon­ey.

Far cheap­er and yet just as effec­tive is the fact that bus man­u­fac­tur­ers began ear­ly on to adapt their designs to the need for improved acces­si­bil­i­ty. Bus­es can be low­ered on the side where pas­sen­gers board. But that is appar­ent­ly not enough for leg­is­la­tors and inter­est­ed par­ties.

Is humanity only used verbally anymore?

I remem­ber a time when pas­sen­gers did­n’t stand at bus stops like frozen pil­lars with their mobile phones in front of their faces. If some­one who had dif­fi­cul­ty walk­ing or was even in a wheel­chair want­ed to get on the bus, peo­ple imme­di­ate­ly offered to help them. Most of the time, you would get a smile and a ‘thank you’ in return, with no ulte­ri­or motives. The same thing hap­pened when a woman want­ed to get on with her pram. It should be not­ed here that we have shot our­selves in the foot with our mod­ern way of think­ing. Any­one who has the mis­for­tune of offer­ing help to a woman in a men­tal­ly dis­tressed state could eas­i­ly be sus­pect­ed of mak­ing cheap advances or even risk being accused of sex­u­al harass­ment. One would have to be able to assess the oth­er per­son, which is becom­ing increas­ing­ly dif­fi­cult in the com­plex­i­ty of degen­er­ate thought pat­terns. So ‘bet­ter to look away!’ is a pro­tec­tive mech­a­nism. This is how we are dig­ging the grave of human inter­ac­tion and help­ful coop­er­a­tion – in more and more areas of life!

At the same time, how­ev­er, terms such as ‘empa­thy’ and ‘human­i­ty’ are being used infla­tion­ar­i­ly. Appar­ent­ly, how­ev­er, only in ver­bal form, for the pur­pose of pos­i­tive self-pre­sen­ta­tion, which seeks to con­vey the image of a con­scious and good per­son.

this page has been automatically translated.

Comments:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ähnliche Beiträge

President and CEO of BMW (Schweiz) AG

Sylvia Neubauer Becomes New CEO of BMW Switzerland

Leadership change at BMW Switzerland: Sylvia Neubauer becomes the new President and CEO from July 2026. The manager with 25 years of experience succeeds Sergio Solero, who returns to Italy.

World Bicycle Day 2026

15 000 cyclists said NO to anti-cycling restrictions

15,000 voices, one clear message: on World Bicycle Day 2026, Pro Velo carried the resistance against new restrictions into parliament. Why the bike vignette and cargo-bike plates caused outrage – and why the National Council had already sent a first signal.

Management change at AMAG Group

Noah Heynen to lead AMAG Energy & Mobility

Noah Heynen became the new Managing Director of AMAG Energy & Mobility. The Board of Directors of AMAG Group AG made this decision. Heynen is co-founder and CEO of Helion Energy AG. He kept this role, because he leads both functions in parallel.